This article is part of the article series "MIT Introduction to Algorithms."
<- previous article next article ->
MIT Algorithms

This is the thirteenth post in an article series about MIT's lecture course "Introduction to Algorithms." In this post I will review lectures twenty and twenty-one on parallel algorithms. These lectures cover the basics of multithreaded programming and multithreaded algorithms.

Lecture twenty begins with a good overview of multithreaded programming paradigm, introduces to various concepts of parallel programming and at the end talks about the Cilk programming language.

Lecture twenty-one implements several multithreaded algorithms, such as nxn matrix addition, nxn matrix multiplication, and parallel merge-sort. It then goes into great detail to analyze the running time and parallelism of these algorithms.

Lecture 20: Parallel Algorithms I

The lecture starts with an introduction to a particular model of parallel computation called dynamic multithreading. It's easiest to understand this model with an example. Here is a multithreaded algorithm that computes Fibonacci numbers:

Fibonacci(n):
1   if n < 2:                     | thread A
2     return n                    | thread A
3   x = spawn Fibonacci(n-1)      | thread A
4   y = spawn Fibonacci(n-2)      | thread B
5   sync                          | thread C
6   return x + y                  | thread C

# this is a really bad algorithm, because it's
# exponential time.
#
# see lecture three for four different
# classical algorithms that compute Fibonacci numbers

(A thread is defined to be a maximal sequence of instructions not containing the parallel control statements spawn, sync, and return, not something like Java threads or Posix threads.)

I put the most important keywords in bold. They are "spawn" and "sync".

The keyword spawn is the parallel analog of an ordinary subroutine call. Spawn before the subroutine call in line 3 indicates that the subprocedure Fibonacci(n-1) can execute in parallel with the procedure Fibonacci(n) itself. Unlike an ordinary function call, where the parent is not resumed until after its child returns, in the case of a spawn, the parent can continue to execute in parallel with the child. In this case, the parent goes on to spawn Fibonacci(n-2). In general, the parent can continue to spawn off children, producing a high degree of parallelism.

A procedure cannot safely use the return values of the children it has spawned until it executes a sync statement. If any of its children have not completed when it executes a sync, the procedure suspends and does not resume until all of its children have completed. When all of its children return, execution of the procedure resumes at the point immediately following the sync statement. In the Fibonacci example, the sync statement in line 5 is required before the return statement in line 6 to avoid the anomaly that would occur if x and y were summed before each had been computed.

The spawn and sync keywords specify logical parallelism, not "actual" parallelism. That is, these keywords indicate which code may possibly execute in parallel, but what actually runs in parallel is determined by a scheduler, which maps the dynamically unfolding computation onto the available processors.

The lecture then continues with a discussion on how a parallel instruction stream can be viewed as a directed acyclic graph G = (V, E), where threads make up the set V of vertices, and each spawn and return statement makes up an edge in E. There are also continuation edges in E that exist between statements.

In Fibonacci example there are three threads: lines 1, 2, 3 make up the thread A, line 4 is thread B and lines 5, 6 are thread C.

Here is how a graph of Fibonacci(4) computation looks like:

Multithreading Directed Acyclic Graph

A dag representing multithreaded computation of Fibonacci(4).

Here the threads are show as circles, and each group of threads belonging to the same procedure are surrounded by a rounded rectangle. Downward edges are spawn dependencies, horizontal edges represent continuation dependencies within a procedure, and upward edges are return dependencies. Every computation starts with a single initial thread, and ends with a single final thread.

So to compute Fib(4), first Fib(3) and Fib(2) have to be computed. Fib(4) spawns one thread to compute Fib(3) and another thread to compute Fib(2) and sync'es. In order to compute Fib(3), values of Fib(2) and Fib(1) have to be known, and to compute Fib(2) values of Fib(1) and Fib(0) have to be known. Fib(3) and Fib(2) spawn their threads and sync. This way the computation unwinds.

Next, the lecture introduces some concepts for measuring performance of multithreaded algorithms.

First some time measures:

  • Tp - running time of an algorithm on p processors,
  • T1 - running time of algorithm on 1 processor, and
  • T as critical path length, that is the longest time to execute the algorithm on infinite number of processors.

Based on these measures, the speedup of a computation on p processors is T1/Tp, that is how much faster a p processor machine executes the algorithm than a one processor machine. If the speedup is O(p), then we say that the computation has a linear speedup. If, however, speedup > p, then we call it a super-linear speedup. The maximum possible speedup is called parallelism and is computed by T1/T.

After these concepts the lecture puts forward the concept of scheduling and greedy scheduler.

A scheduler maps computation to p processors.

The greedy scheduler schedules as much as it can at every time step. On a p-processor machine every step can be classified into two types. If there are p or more threads ready to execute, the scheduler executes any p of them (this step is also called a complete step). If there are fewer than p threads, it executes all of them (called incomplete step). The greedy scheduler is an offline scheduler and it's 2-competitive (see lecture 13 on online/offline algorithms and the meaning of competitive algorithm).

The lecture ends with an introduction to Cilk parallel, multithreaded programming language. It uses a randomized online scheduler. It was used to write two chess programs *Socrates and Cilkchess.

See Charles Leiseron's handout for a much more comprehensive overview of dynamic multithreading: A Minicourse on Dynamic Multithreaded Algorithms (pdf).

You're welcome to watch lecture twenty:

Topics covered in lecture twenty:

  • [01:33] Parallel algorithms.
  • [02:33] Dynamic multi-threading.
  • [03:15] A multithreaded algorithm for fibonnaci numbers.
  • [04:50] Explanation of spawn and sync.
  • [06:45] Logical parallelism.
  • [08:00] Multithreaded computation.
  • [12:15] Fibonacci(4) computation graph, and its concepts - init thread, spawn edge, continuation edge, return edge, final thread.
  • [17:45] Edges: spawn, return, continuation.
  • [19:40] Performance measures: running time on p processors Tp, work (serial time) T1, critcial path length (longest path) Tinfinity.
  • [24:15] Lower bounds on Tp (running time on p processors).
  • [29:35] Speedup, linear speedup, superlinear speedup.
  • [32:55] Maximum possible speedup.
  • [36:40] Scheduling.
  • [38:55] Greedy scheduler.
  • [43:40] Theorem by Grant and Brent (bound on Tp for greedy scheduler).
  • [46:20] Proof of Grant, Brent theorem.
  • [56:50] Corollary on greedy scheduler's linear speedup.
  • [01:02:20] Cilk programming language.
  • [01:06:00] Chess programs: *Socrates, Clikchess.
  • [01:06:30] Analysis of *Socrates running time on 512 processors.

Lecture twenty notes:

MIT Algorithms Lecture 20 Notes Thumbnail. Page 1 of 2.
Lecture 20, page 1 of 2: dynamic multithreading, multithreaded computation, performance measures, speedup, scheduling, greedy scheduler.

MIT Algorithms Lecture 20 Notes Thumbnail. Page 2 of 2.
Lecture 20, page 2 of 2: grant, brent theorem, cilk, socrates, cilkchess.

Lecture 21: Parallel Algorithms II

Lecture twenty-one is all about real multithreaded algorithms and their analysis.

It starts with a hugly important problem of multithreaded matrix multiplication: given two nxn matrices A and B, write a multithreaded algorithm Matrix-Multiply that multiplies them, producing matrix C. The natural approach is to use divide and conquer method from lecture three, and formulate the problem as follows:

Multithreaded Matrix Multiplication

Each nxn matrix can be expressed as 8 multiplications and 4 additions of (n/2)x(n/2) submatrices. So the first thing we need is Matrix-Add algorithm that adds two matrices in parallel.

Here is the parallel Matrix-Add algorithm:

Matrix-Add(C, T, n):
   // Adds matrices C and T in-place, producing C = C + T
   // n is power of 2 (for simplicity).
   if  n == 1:
     C[1, 1] = C[1, 1] + T[1, 1] 
   else:
     partition C and T into (n/2)x(n/2) submatrices
     spawn Matrix-Add(C11, T11, n/2) 
     spawn Matrix-Add(C12, T12, n/2) 
     spawn Matrix-Add(C21, T21, n/2) 
     spawn Matrix-Add(C22, T22, n/2) 
     sync 

The base case for this algorithm is when matrices are just scalars, then it just adds the only element of both matrices. In all other cases, it partitions matrices C and T into (n/2)x(n/2) matrices and spawns four subproblems.

Now we can implement the Matrix-Multiply algorithm, by doing 8 multiplications in parallel and then calling Matrix-Add to do 4 additions.

Here is the parallel Matrix-Multiply algorithm:

Matrix-Multiply(C, A, B, n):
   // Multiplies matrices A and B, storing the result in C.
   // n is power of 2 (for simplicity).
   if  n == 1:
     C[1, 1] = A[1, 1] · B[1, 1] 
   else:
     allocate a temporary matrix T[1...n, 1...n] 
     partition A, B, C, and T into (n/2)x(n/2) submatrices 
     spawn Matrix-Multiply(C12,A11,B12, n/2) 
     spawn Matrix-Multiply(C21,A21,B11, n/2) 
     spawn Matrix-Multiply(C22,A21,B12, n/2) 
     spawn Matrix-Multiply(T11,A12,B21, n/2) 
     spawn Matrix-Multiply(T12,A12,B22, n/2) 
     spawn Matrix-Multiply(T21,A22,B21, n/2) 
     spawn Matrix-Multiply(T22,A22,B22, n/2) 
     sync 
     Matrix-Add(C, T, n)

The lecture then proceeds to calculating how good the algorithm is, turns out the parallelism (ratio of time of algorithm running on a single processor T1 to running on infinite number of processors Tinf) for doing 1000x1000 matrix multiplication is 107, which the parallel algorithm is fast as hell.

Matrix-Multiply used a temporary matrix which was actually unnecessary. To achieve higher performance, it's often advantageous for an algorithm to use less space, because more space means more time. Therefore a faster algorithm can be added that multiplies matrices and adds them in-place. See lecture at 33:05 for Matrix-Multiply-Add algorithm. The parallelism of this algorithm for 1000x1000 matrix multiplication is 106, smaller than the previous one, but due to fact that no temporary matrices had to be used, it beats Matrix-Multiply algorithm in practice.

The lecture then proceeds to parallel sorting. The classical sorting algorithms were covered in lectures four and five. This lecture parallelizes the Merge-Sort algorithm.

Here is the parallel merge-sort algorithm:

Parallel-Merge-Sort(A, p, r): // sort A[p...r]
  if p < r:
    q = floor((p+r)/2)
    spawn Parallel-Merge-Sort(A, p, q)
    spawn Parallel-Merge-Sort(A, q+1, r)
    sync
    Merge(A, p, q, r) // merge A[p...q] with A[q+1...r]

Instead of recursively calling Parallel-Merge-Sort for subproblems, we spawn them, thus utilizing the power of parallelism. After doing analysis turns out that due to fact that we use the classical Merge() function, the parallelism is just lg(n). That's puny!

To solve this problem, a Parallel-Merge algorithm has to be written. The lecture continues with presenting a Parallel-Merge algorithm, and after that does the analysis of the same Parallel-Merge-Sort algorithm but with Parallel-Merge function. Turns out this algorithm has parallelism of n/lg2(n), that is much better. See lecture at 51:00 for Parallel-Merge algorithm.

The best parallel sorting algorithm know to date has the parallelism of n/lg(n).

You're welcome to watch lecture twenty-one:

Topics covered in lecture twenty-one:

  • [00:35] Multithreaded algorithms.
  • [01:32] Multithreaded matrix multiplication.
  • [02:05] Parallelizing with divide and conquer.
  • [04:30] Algorithm Matrix-Multiply, that computes C = A*B.
  • [10:13] Algorithm Matrix-Add, that computes C = C+T.
  • [12:45] Analysis of running time of Matrix-Multiply and Matrix-Add.
  • [19:40] Analysis of critical path length of Matrix-Multiply and Matrix-Add.
  • [26:10] Parallelism of Matrix-Multiply and Matrix-Add.
  • [33:05] Algorithm Matrix-Multiply-Add, that computes C = C + A*B.
  • [35:50] Analysis of Matrix-Multiply-Add.
  • [42:30] Multithreaded, parallel sorting.
  • [43:30] Parallelized Merge-Sort algorithm.
  • [45:55] Analysis of multithreaded Merge-Sort.
  • [51:00] Parallel-Merge algorithm.
  • [01:00:30] Analysis of Parallel-Merge algorithm.

Lecture twenty-one notes:

MIT Algorithms Lecture 21 Notes Thumbnail. Page 1 of 2.
Lecture 21, page 1 of 2: multithreaded algorithms, matrix multiplication, analysis (critical path length, parallelism).

MIT Algorithms Lecture 21 Notes Thumbnail. Page 2 of 2.
Lecture 21, page 2 of 2: paralel sorting, merge sort, parallel merge, analysis.

Have fun with parallel, multithreaded algorithms! The next post is going to be on cache oblivious algorithms! They are a class of algorithms that exploit all the various caches in modern computer architecture to make them run notably faster.

This article is part of the article series "MIT Introduction to Algorithms."
<- previous article next article ->

Comments

March 07, 2009, 21:48

Interesting post and an informative write-up. Thanks!

March 08, 2009, 02:23

I just want you to know how much I appreciate the amount of effort you've put into this. In particular, I like the way you made your notes and put them up. I'm currently going through the old MIT SICP videos myself.

spyk_em Permalink
March 08, 2009, 18:32

Excellent series, I've already watched all of the previous parts.

Thanks and keep up!

http://www.advernation.com Permalink
April 02, 2009, 04:01

very nice post made me refresh and it all came back to me now

November 27, 2009, 05:13

excelent work
keep up, it's very usefull!

Seh Permalink
October 06, 2010, 20:27

Thanks buddy! It was very helpful...

RQueck Permalink
January 13, 2011, 20:38

Parallel Matrix-Multiply algorithm misses line:
spawn Matrix-Multiply(C11,A11,B11, n/2)

NASHON MUTONGI Permalink
March 26, 2011, 18:27

indeed its a wonderful site for informatiion technology addicts.

jim Permalink
April 06, 2011, 07:06

In the handout (lecture 21, page 2 of 2), the critical path length for mergesort with plain merge (not parallel merge) was given as T_inf(n) = T_inf(n/2) + Theta(1) = Theta(n).
Shouldn't this be T_inf(n) = T_inf(n/2) + Theta(n) = Theta(n)?

jim Permalink
April 06, 2011, 07:25

Checked the video. The notes were wrong. The video was right with
T_inf(n) = T_inf(n/2) + Theta(n) = Theta(n).
Otherwise the result would have been Theta(log n).

Bhaskar B Permalink
September 02, 2011, 17:35

The notesu've prepared n lecture was so nice.
Thanks for your efforts.

Actually I'm preparing for yahoo/microsoft/google interview.
It is very helpful.
Thanks again.
Request all to send related interview questions if possible..

saswata Permalink
September 17, 2012, 11:00

Nice post buddy... came here after searching for lectures 20,21.
BTW could you re-upload the lectures ?
(They seem to be missing and the MIT OCW site doesn't have them either)

asdf Permalink
May 23, 2014, 17:34
asdf Permalink
May 23, 2014, 17:34
asdf Permalink
May 23, 2014, 17:34
June 04, 2014, 06:02

Interesting post and an informative write-up. Thanks!

faheen Permalink
June 22, 2014, 04:15

Ramadan Wallpaper
Ramadan Wallpaper HD Download
Ramadan Wallpaper 2014
Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 Download
Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 HD Images
Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 Images
Ramadan Wallpaper quotes
Ramadan wallpaper greetings
Ramadan wallpaper 2014 greetings
Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 quotes
Ramadan Kareem 2014 images
Ramadan Kareem Mubarak Images
Ramadan Kareem Mubarak 2014 images
Ramadan Screen Saver 2014 download
Ramadan Mubarak images
Ramadan images 2014
Ramadan Mubarak greetings
Wish you happy Ramadan 2014
Happy Ramadan Wallpaper 2014
Ramadan wallpaper 2014
Wish you happy Ramadan 2014
ramadan Hd wallpaper 2014
Wish you happy Ramadan wallpaper 2014
Ramadan 2014 images
Ramadan 2014 pictures
wish you happy Ramadan 2014 images
Wish you happy Ramadan 2014 pictures
Happy ramadan 2014 wallpaper
Ramadan Kareem 2014 Wallpaper
Ramadan Mubarak 2014 wallpaper
Wallpaper Ramadan 2014
Ramadan HD wallpaper
Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper
wish you Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper
Happy Ramadan HD wallpaper
Happy Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper
Wish you Ramadan HD wallpaper Download 2014
Ramadan HD wallpaper Download 2014
Ramadan HD wallpaper 2014 Download
Ramadan HD wallpaper 1080p
Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper 1080p
Best Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper
Top 10 Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper
Best Collections Of Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper
Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper For Android
Ramadan 2014 best Screensaver download
Ramadan 2014 Screensaver download
screensaver download for mobile Ramadan 2014
Ramadan 2014 HD Screensaver Download
Ramadan 2014 download best screen saver
Screensaver for 2014 ramadan
Ramadan mubarak screensaver download
Ramadan mubarak 2014 best screen saver
Ramadan Kareem Mubarak 2014 best screen saver
Ramadan mubarak 2014 best screen saver
screen saver 2014 download free for android
Ramadan Kareem Mubarak Greetings 2014
Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 Greetings
Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 Greetings
Top Collections of Ramadan 2014 Greetings
Ramadan 2014 Greetings
Ramadan 2014 Greetings Free
Ramadan 2014 Greetings Kareem best
Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 Kareem Greetings
Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 Kareem Greetings
Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 kareem greetings
Top Ramadan 2014 wallpapers
Top Ramadan 2014 pictures
Top ramadan 2014 pictures for pc
Top ramadan 2014 Wallpaper for Android
Ramadan 2014 best softwares
Ramadan 2014 Best Images of Desktop
Ramadan 2014 best pictures for desktop
ramadan 2014 collection of Hd wallpaper
Ramadan 2014 Best collections
Ramadan 2014 top Hd wallpaper
Ramadan 2014 in uk
When Ramadan 2014 in Uk
ramadan 2014 in United Kingdom
When Ramadan 2014 in United States
When ramadan 2014 in America
Ramadan date in uk
Ramadan date in uk
Ramadan facts in united kingdom
Ramadan date in France
Ramadan 2014 in france
Ramadan 2014 date in france
Ramadan 2014 date in Frace country
Happy Ramadan 2014 best wallpaper
Ramadan Wallpaper best collections
Ramadan Kareem Wallpaper collections
wish you happy Ramadan wallpaper 2014
happy Ramadan wallpaper 2014
wish you happy Ramadan Hd wallpaper
Happy Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper
Hd Ramadan wallpaper 2014
Wallpaper 2014 Hd in Ramadan
Ramadan wallpaper 2014 for Desktop Background
Best Islamic Ramadan wallpaper 2014
Wallpaper 2014 for facebook Cover
Best Wallpaper 2014 Download
Ramadan HD wallpaper 2014 Download
When ramadan in India 2014
Ramadan in India 2014
Ramadan in India 2014
Ramadan Kareem Greetings
Ramadan kareem Mubarak Greetings
Ramadan kareeem 2014 Greetings
Ramadan 2014 kareem Greetings
Ramadan 2014 kareem greetings
Ramadan Kareem Mubarak 2014
Ramadan kareem Mubarak 2014
Ramadan kareem Mubarak 2014
Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014
Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014
Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014
Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014
Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics
Awesome Post Ramadan Wallpaper Ramadan Wallpaper HD Download Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 Download Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 HD Images Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 Images Ramadan Wallpaper quotes Ramadan wallpaper greetings Ramadan wallpaper 2014 greetings Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 quotes Ramadan Kareem 2014 images Ramadan Kareem Mubarak Images Ramadan Kareem Mubarak 2014 images Ramadan Screen Saver 2014 download Ramadan Mubarak images Ramadan images 2014 Ramadan Mubarak greetings Wish you happy Ramadan 2014 Happy Ramadan Wallpaper 2014 Ramadan wallpaper 2014 Wish you happy Ramadan 2014 ramadan Hd wallpaper 2014 Wish you happy Ramadan wallpaper 2014 Ramadan 2014 images Ramadan 2014 pictures wish you happy Ramadan 2014 images Wish you happy Ramadan 2014 pictures Happy ramadan 2014 wallpaper Ramadan Kareem 2014 Wallpaper Ramadan Mubarak 2014 wallpaper Wallpaper Ramadan 2014 Ramadan HD wallpaper Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper wish you Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper Happy Ramadan HD wallpaper Happy Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper Wish you Ramadan HD wallpaper Download 2014 Ramadan HD wallpaper Download 2014 Ramadan HD wallpaper 2014 Download Ramadan HD wallpaper 1080p Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper 1080p Best Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper Top 10 Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper Best Collections Of Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper For Android Ramadan 2014 best Screensaver download Ramadan 2014 Screensaver download screensaver download for mobile Ramadan 2014 Ramadan 2014 HD Screensaver Download Ramadan 2014 download best screen saver Screensaver for 2014 ramadan Ramadan mubarak screensaver download Ramadan mubarak 2014 best screen saver Ramadan Kareem Mubarak 2014 best screen saver Ramadan mubarak 2014 best screen saver screen saver 2014 download free for android Ramadan Kareem Mubarak Greetings 2014 Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 Greetings Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 Greetings Top Collections of Ramadan 2014 Greetings Ramadan 2014 Greetings Ramadan 2014 Greetings Free Ramadan 2014 Greetings Kareem best Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 Kareem Greetings Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 Kareem Greetings Best Collections of Ramadan 2014 kareem greetings Top Ramadan 2014 wallpapers Top Ramadan 2014 pictures Top ramadan 2014 pictures for pc Top ramadan 2014 Wallpaper for Android Ramadan 2014 best softwares Ramadan 2014 Best Images of Desktop Ramadan 2014 best pictures for desktop ramadan 2014 collection of Hd wallpaper Ramadan 2014 Best collections Ramadan 2014 top Hd wallpaper Ramadan 2014 in uk When Ramadan 2014 in Uk ramadan 2014 in United Kingdom When Ramadan 2014 in United States When ramadan 2014 in America Ramadan date in uk Ramadan date in uk Ramadan facts in united kingdom Ramadan date in France Ramadan 2014 in france Ramadan 2014 date in france Ramadan 2014 date in Frace country Happy Ramadan 2014 best wallpaper Ramadan Wallpaper best collections Ramadan Kareem Wallpaper collections wish you happy Ramadan wallpaper 2014 happy Ramadan wallpaper 2014 wish you happy Ramadan Hd wallpaper Happy Ramadan 2014 HD wallpaper Hd Ramadan wallpaper 2014 Wallpaper 2014 Hd in Ramadan Ramadan wallpaper 2014 for Desktop Background Best Islamic Ramadan wallpaper 2014 Wallpaper 2014 for facebook Cover Best Wallpaper 2014 Download Ramadan HD wallpaper 2014 Download When ramadan in India 2014 Ramadan in India 2014 Ramadan in India 2014 Ramadan Kareem Greetings Ramadan kareem Mubarak Greetings Ramadan kareeem 2014 Greetings Ramadan 2014 kareem Greetings Ramadan 2014 kareem greetings Ramadan Kareem Mubarak 2014 Ramadan kareem Mubarak 2014 Ramadan kareem Mubarak 2014 Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014 Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014 Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014 Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014 Ramadan Kareem greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Ramadan Mubarak Greetings 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Inspirational pictures of ramadan 2014 Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics Ramadan 2014 Wallpaper and Mubarak pics oHack Anna University Paper Valuation Anna University result 2014 Thanks for sharing

tot Permalink
June 28, 2014, 10:17

clear and informative. I just feel your blog is my worth. thanks a lot!

Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club.

clear and informative. I just feel your blog is my worth. thanks a lot!

Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club Fast Income Club Review Fast Income Club.

yeshwanth Permalink
July 10, 2014, 08:38
DEEPU Permalink
July 10, 2014, 08:52
July 20, 2014, 18:08

Actually this post is about my personal interest and the mid of the post is truly informative and I love and elaboration quality of writer. I always try to find this type of info regarding this topic now here I got this thanks Happy Friendship Day SMS Friendship Day SMS Independence Day Images Happy Independence Day Images Independence Day Images India India Independence Day independence day speech independence day sms independence day wallpaper independence day message independence day songs again thanks for this great blog.

Yeshu Permalink
July 23, 2014, 12:10

After read a couple of the articles on your website these few days, and I truly like your style of blogging.
I tag it to my favorites internet site list and will be checking back soon.
Please check out my web site also and let me know what you think.
ramadan mubarak messages
ramadan mubarak message
ramadan quotes
ramadan mubarak images
ramadan pictures.

Leave a new comment

(why do I need your e-mail?)

(Your twitter name, if you have one. (I'm @pkrumins, btw.))

Type the first letter of your name: (just to make sure you're a human)

Please preview the comment before submitting to make sure it's OK.

Advertisements