Style distinguishes excellence from accomplishment.
I am doing a startup!
Cross-browser testing from your browser!
I have written my fourth book!
Be faster than Larry Wall in the shell!
You're viewing a comment by rajiv and its responses.
>> fmap id = id
I think the above identity is not quite right. It has different types on either side of the "=" sign. And I think that's a consequence of the fact that a functor maps the identity of the morphisms of one category to that of another - the two identities belong to different categories, not the same as the above identity indicates.
In the case of lists probably the right identity is
map id = [id]. If I check the types for the list identity
map id :: [b] -> [b]
[id] :: [a -> a]
I'm not quite sure if this makes sense, but it feels right. (I'm a Haskell novice.)
And I have no idea how to express this for general functors.
It is correct.
Hugs> fmap id [1,2,3]
Hugs> id [1,2,3]
Hugs> fmap id [1,2,3] == id [1,2,3]
(why do I need your e-mail?)
It would be nice if you left your e-mail address. Sometimes I want to send a private message, or just thank for the great comment. Having your e-mail really helps.
I will never ever spam you.
(Your twitter handle, if you have one.)
* use <pre>...</pre> to insert a plain code snippet.
* use <pre lang="lang">...</pre> to insert a syntax highlighted code snippet.
For example, <pre lang="python">...</pre> will insert Python highlighted code.
* use <code>...</code> to highlight a variable or a single shell command.
* use <a href="url" nospam>title</a> to insert links.
<a href="url" nospam>title</a>
* use other HTML tags, such as, <b>, <i>, <blockquote>, <sup>, <sub> for text formatting.
Type the word "sandbox_219": (just to make sure you're a human)
Please preview the comment before submitting to make sure it's OK.
Peter Krumins' blog about programming, hacking, software reuse, software ideas, computer security, browserling, google and technology.
Reach me at:
Or meet me on:
Subscribe through an RSS feed:
Subscribe through email:
Enter your email address:
Delivered by FeedBurner
See all top articles
See all downloads
See more detailed list of recent articles
See more detailed category information
See more detailed list of all articles